Introduction
According to the National Family Health Survey (NFHS)
42 percent of married Indian women use modern methods
of contraception; less than 7 percent of currently married
women use one of the three major spacing methods (oral
contraceptives, condoms, intra- uterine devices). Another
estimate by NFHS 2 reports that 21 percent of all pregnancies
contraception can prevent unwanted pregnancy following
unprotected intercourse.
In
this context the importance of increasing awareness
and utilisation of Emergency Contraceptive Services
is evident. An important method of Emergency Contraception
(EC) is the progesterone only pill, levonorgestrel (LNG).
In Bangladesh, emergency contraception is dispensed
even by field level extension workers. However, in India,
this was hitherto available only on a doctor’s
prescription.
The
authors are : Junior Research Fellow, RCCHR; Professor
and Head, Dept of Obst. & Gynae., Principal Investigator,
RCCHR; Research Officer, RCCHR; Research Officer, RCCHR;
at ICMR, Seth GS Medical College and KEM Hospital; Public
Health Nurse, Palghar Taluka, Thane Dist., respectively. |
There
data is not available on the feasibility of training
Auxiliary Nurse Midwives and other paramedical staff
in rural In dia
for distribution of EC pills through the public health
network. This study was carried out to determine whether
Indian nurses and paramedical workers could be trained
to dispense EC pills.
Objective This paper evaluates the
impact of training about Emergency Contraceptive Pills
on Auxiliary Nurse Midwives, Lady Health Visitors, Health
Assistants, Multi Purpose Workers and Pharmacists in
order to assess whether dispensing of E pills by them
is feasible.
A
multicentric study on “Utilisation of EC service
through paramedics in India” was planned by Indian
Council of Medical Research (ICMR) in collaboration
with Population Council. ICMR’s Regional Centre
for Clinical Research in Human Reproduction (RCCHR)
in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Seth
GS Medical College and King Edward Memorial Hospital,
Mumbai is one of the participating centres in collaboration
with Department of
Health,
Government of Maharashtra. Methods Trainees:
102 Auxiliary Nurse Midwives, Lady Health Visitors,
Health Assistants, Multi Purpose
|
Workers and Pharmacists from Palghar taluka were given
a day-long training (6 hour-session) in 5 batches. Trainers:
The training was imparted by faculty from Seth GS Medical
College and KEM Hospital, officers from ICMR Headquarters
and Population Council, Representative of DHO, Thane,
District training faculty, RCCHR (KEM) and EC project
staff. Training was mainly under the following heads
: Need for the research, Training of trainers, Counselling
skills, A role play in which trainees acted as provider
and client for E pills.
Instruments:
Identical, prestructured pre- and post-training questionnaires
in Marathi (local language) were administered just before
and after the training session, to assess the existing
knowledge regarding emergency contraception services
and the impact of the training on them. Disclosure of
identity was optional. Questions were provided with
multiple choice answers; some had more than one correct
answer. This was clearly
explained to the participants. Marks were allotted as
follows: (i) 1 for a correct answer, and (ii) 0 for
no answer or wrong answer Marks obtained per question
were added and the difference in pre- and post-training
scores was statistically analysed. Results:
68.13% trainees were
|
|
aware
about Emergency Contraceptive pills before training,
this awareness increased to 95 percent post-training.
The time of taking EC pills was identified correctly
by 75.49 percent post-training as compared to only 32.6
percent pre-training; 95 percent trainees correctly
mentioned 2 doses post-training as compared to 58.76
percent pretraining. Post training increase in knowledge
was statistically significant.
Discussion Emergency contraception
prevents an unwanted pregnancy in the event of unprotected
sexual intercourse. Combination pills containing LNG
and ethinylestradiol have now made way for the progesterone
only pill containing LNG. LNG was first introduced as
an EC pill in the National Health Care Programme by
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in 2001, to be
dispensed only by doctors. In India the unmet need for
family planning (a situation of wanting to avoid or
postpone child bearing but not using any contraception)
is 16 percent. The WHO estimates that annually unintended
pregnancies lead to nearly 20 million unsafe abortions
worldwide, resulting in 80,000 maternal deaths. In India,
6.7 million abortions are performed every year in unrecognised
centres, often by untrained persons in unhygienic conditions.
The unmet need for emergency contraception is evident.
EC is available without prescription in 26 countries
(Source: The American Society for Emergency
Contraception, current as on November 7, 2002). Emergency
|
contraception has significantly reduced the US abortion
rate. In 2000- 2001, the Alan Guttmacher Institute surveyed
all US abortion providers and more than 10,000 women
who had undergone abortion.
An
estimated 51,000 abortions were averted by use of emergency
contraceptives in 2000; emergency contraceptives accounted
for upto 43% of the decrease in total abortions between
1994 and 2000. E pills are available in US only on prescription
but are easily accessible. The abortion rate in France
(which is half the US rate) is one of the lowest in
the world at 12 per 1,000 women aged 14-44.
The
French Government in June 1999 granted EC pills a nonprescription
status and also made them available free of cost at
family planning clinics; 97 percent of the 1.5 million
pills were sold without a prescription with no reported
adverse effects. In Netherlands, where emergency contraception
is easily available to women, abortion rates are one
of the lowest (8.4 per 1000 women of 15-44 age group).
Levonorgestrel
was made available without prescription in Netherlands
from January 2005. The South Africa Medicines Control
Council in 2000 allowed pharmacies to sell levonorgestrel
(Norlevo) without prescription. Emergency contraceptives
are also available free of charge at public health facilities
in South Africa, where
|
staff provide pills along with regularoral contraceptive
packets. In the current study, knowledge about Emergency
Contraceptive pills (ECP) of the ANMs and other paramedics
was 33.33 percent prior to training and 66.12 percent
post-training. The results show that the paramedical
staff ’s knowledge and concepts regarding Emergency
Contraception improved considerably after the training
session. The increase was found to be statistically
significant.
In
the rural healthcare setup Primary Health Centres (PHC)
are very often manned by male doctors. For example,
of the 13 doctors from 8 PHCs in the intervention areas
(Palghar), 12 were males. It is unlikely that rural
Indian women would approach a male doctor for EC pills.
Tribal women usually stay far away from the PHC; they
would not spend money and time travelling for an emergency
pill. Involvement of Auxiliary Nurses and other paramedical
staff who are close by and well known to the women,
will certainly improve the utilisation of E pills. Our
study shows that the ANMs had increased knowledge after
training was adequate for safe dispensing of E pills
by them.
The
inference therefore strengthens the view that paramedical
staff services can be utilised to dispense E pills.
This is the research question that will be studied in
depth during the project “Studying the Utilisation
of Emergency Contraceptive Services through Paramedics
in India”. It would be useful to know if the experience
in China and Bangladesh
|
|
(which
report that abortion rates have fallen by 50 percent
and 32 percent respectively after introduction of dispensing
E pills by paramedical staff) can be duplicated in India.
An easy access to E pills will help in avoiding unwanted
pregnancies and unsafe abortions.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to ICMR, Population Council, Department
of Health, Government of Maharashtra, District Health
Officer and staff of Thane District for making the study
possible and to Mr Shrinivas Gurav for statistical analysis.
References
1.http://www.unQ)a.org.in/ country_profile.htm. accessed
|
on
20 May 2006 2. Lori Ashford. Unmet need for Family planning
: Recent Trends and Their Implications for Programs, Population
Reference Bureau 3. Abortion Assessment Project- India
(AAPI): A Brief Profile -CEHAT (Centre for Enquiry into
Health and Allied Themes)
http://www.cehat.org/aapl/obj.pdf
accessed on 20 May 2006 4. Heather Boonstra, Emergency
Contraception: Steps Being Taken to Improve Access : The
Guttmacher Report on Public Policy, Volume 5, Number 5,
December 2002, http://www.guttmacher.Org/
pubs/tgr/Q5/5/gr05Q510. html, accessed on 20 May 2006
5. http://www.nlembassv. Qrg.vu/contents/download/
|
abortion_policv.pdf
accessed on 20 May 2006 6. http://www.ibisreproductive
heaith.org/pub/downloads/ EC strategy mtg final report
.pdf. accessed on 20 May 2006 7. UNDP/UNFPA/WHO/World
bank Special Programme of Research Development and Research
Training in Human Reproduction 2001. Use of Emergency
Contraceptive
Pills could have the Induced Abortion Rate in Shanghai,
China Social Science research Policy Briefs. Series 2
no. 1 8. Khan ME, Hossain SMI, Rahman M (2004). Report
on Emergency Contraception in Bangladesh: Using Operations
Research for policy decision Population Council. http://www.pop
council.org/ pdfs/frontiers/ FR FinalReports/Bang EC.pdf
accessed on 20 May 2006 |
::
POLICY & POSITION STATEMENT :: RESOURCES & PUBLICATION :: THE NURSING JOURNAL OF INDIA
MEMBERSHIP DETAILS :: ADVERTISE WITH US :: EVENT DIARY :: WHAT'S NEW :: SIGN OUR GUEST BOOK :: CONTACT US :: NURSE PLEDGE
Trained Nurses' Association of India (TNAI)
|
|